Myth, checked
Are Men Smarter Than Women?
Sperm whale brains are six times heavier than ours. An elephant's brain is three times bigger than a human's.
The Brain on the Stand
Case Number 24: Who is smarter? Man versus Woman. It's a question as old as arguments themselves. The charge on the docket today is that one is fundamentally, biologically, smarter than the other. We're putting that belief on trial.
The prosecution's first piece of evidence is Exhibit A: the male brain. It's a simple, physical fact that on average, a man's brain is about ten percent larger by volume than a woman's. For many, the case seems closed right there.
But the defense raises a crucial objection. If size equaled smarts, we'd be bowing to sperm whales, whose brains are six times heavier than ours. Even an elephant's brain is three times bigger. Size isn't intelligence. The case for brute size is dismissed.
The real story is the wiring. Brain scans reveal something fascinating. Women's brains often show denser connections between the left and right hemispheres. It's a different design, not defective. Which brain 'fact' were you taught in school? Tell us below.
The IQ Test Fraud
The next witness is the IQ test, used for a century to measure intelligence. Our man and woman sit for the exam. The assumption is a single number can finally tell us who is smarter.
The scores are in. It's a dead heat. When you average the scores of millions, the average IQ for men and women is identical. The gap is zero. The prosecution's case falters.
But the average hides a crucial detail. Men's scores are more variable–more at the very top and the very bottom. Women's scores are more tightly grouped around the middle. The shape of the bell curve is different.
And the test itself is flawed. It's like judging a fish by its ability to climb a tree. It tells you nothing about creativity, wisdom, or social intelligence. Save this for the next argument about IQ.
The Verdict
The trial of man versus woman for the 'smarter' title rests on a flawed premise. We ask 'who is smarter?'. The evidence demands we ask 'how are they smart?'. Intelligence isn't a single trophy to be won.
A better model is a toolbox. Both our man and our woman have a full set of tools. While their toolboxes are 99% identical, there are slight average differences in specialties: spatial reasoning for men, verbal fluency for women.
The verdict is in. The belief that one gender is smarter is found guilty. It ignores the beautiful complexity of the mind. The truth is collaboration. Send this to the one person who still needs to hear it.
Their brains are not identical, but they are absolutely equivalent. Two different keys, each beautifully crafted to unlock the same world. What other "facts" need a trial?
Every claim, checked
This is the whole list, including the ones we could not confirm. How this works is written down in how we check things.
On average, a man's brain is about ten percent larger by volume than a woman's brain.VerifiedPeer-reviewed review, 'Review: MRI of male/female differences in human adolescent brain anatomy' (PMC3472204); Ruigrok et al., meta-analysis, University of Cambridge, published in Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews (2014)
Sperm whale brains are six times heavier than ours.VerifiedWhale and Dolphin Conservation (WDC), 'Which whale has the biggest brain?'
An elephant's brain is three times bigger than a human's.VerifiedHerculano-Houzel, Avelino-de-Souza et al., 'The elephant brain in numbers,' Frontiers in Neuroanatomy (2014)
Women's brains often show denser connections between the left and right hemispheres, described as a different design not defective.VerifiedIngalhalikar et al., 'Sex differences in the structural connectome of the human brain,' PNAS (2014); critique by Joel et al. and 'On the mis-presentation and misinterpretation of gender-related data' (2014)
The IQ test has been used for a century to measure intelligence.VerifiedBinet, A., & Simon, T. (1905), 'Méthodes nouvelles pour le diagnostic du niveau intellectuel des anormaux,' L'Année Psychologique
When you average the scores of millions, the average IQ for men and women is identical, the gap is zero.VerifiedGiofrè et al., 'The Impasse on Gender Differences in Intelligence: a Meta-Analysis on WISC Batteries,' Educational Psychology Review (2022)
Men's scores are more variable–more at the very top and the very bottom–while women's scores are more tightly grouped around the middle.VerifiedHedges, L.V., & Nowell, A., 'Sex Differences in Mental Test Scores, Variability, and Numbers of High-Scoring Individuals,' Science (1995)
Both a man and a woman have a full set of cognitive tools, with their toolboxes 99% identical.UnverifiedNo study was found that quantifies overall cognitive similarity between the sexes as a specific '99%' figure; this appears to be an illustrative analogy rather than a published statistic, though research does support broad overall similarity with only modest average differences in specific domains.
Slight average differences in specialties: spatial reasoning for men, verbal fluency for women.VerifiedHirnstein, Stuebs, Moè & Hausmann, 'Sex/Gender Differences in Verbal Fluency and Verbal-Episodic Memory: A Meta-Analysis,' Perspectives on Psychological Science (2023); Halpern, D.F., 'Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities' (2000)
People also ask
Is the male brain bigger than the female brain?
Yes, on average a man's brain is about ten percent larger by volume than a woman's. However, the article notes that brain size is not a measure of intelligence, as other animals have much larger brains than humans.
Do men and women have the same average IQ?
Yes, the average IQ for men and women is identical. After averaging the scores of millions of people, the measured gap between the two is zero.
How do IQ scores differ between men and women?
Although the average score is the same, the distribution of scores is different. Men's scores are more variable, with more men scoring at the very highest and lowest ends, while women's scores are more concentrated around the average.
Are IQ tests a good measure of overall intelligence?
No, the article describes the test as flawed for measuring total intelligence. It does not account for other important qualities like creativity, wisdom, or social intelligence.
One myth a week, redrawn.
One email per video: the myth, what's actually true, and links to the research. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.